Saturday, November 21, 2026

I am “Sister” (but it’s more complicated than that)

 

I’ve thought a lot about the recent SNL “Sister” skit. I am sister but there is so much more to it than just being the person in the family as the designated caregiver.

In fact, I wrote about it years ago in my book “Forever a Caregiver” which is all about appreciating family, accepting our role and finding fulfillment. And I even wrote this book before I took in my disabled brother, Robert!

Yes, I am the family caregiver.

I’m not mad or resentful at my other brother, Rich. He was always supportive even though he wasn’t going to be the one to physically care for our brother. In fact, one year I was having trouble finding respite care so my husband and I could take a vacation after years of caring for him and I joked that I would bring Robert to his house. He teased right back that instead he would pay for a facility for him.

I knew Rich wasn’t the caregiver and he knew my husband and I did a great job caring for Robert so helped in the way he could.

You know who else knew I would be the caregiver?

The healthcare system. I was the one at the hospital with Robert making sure he got the care he needed. I was the advocate in the emergency room handing them a Care Summary which included all of his insurance information, list of medications and his doctors’ contact information.

Doctors and nurses would comment what a great sister I was. One even told me that it was common for people to be left in the hospital because the caregiver could no longer do it. They called this “dumping.”

Finally, after ten years caring for Robert, and adding my husband’s mom to our household and also caring for my husband with leg ulcers needing multiple surgeries, (oh and working full-time in a demanding job) I had a stroke.

Luckily, it was minor. I don’t have any lingering deficits but since they couldn’t pinpoint the cause, I was told it was most likely due to stress.

Ya think?

So I made changes. I hired a housekeeper to come in once a week. I scheduled regular massages. I started taking medication for high blood pressure and was also put on a blood thinner.

Did I stop caregiving? 

Nope.

How could I? My brother was disabled, our parents had died years earlier and my other brother was not going to take him in.

I knew this was not sustainable. It’s possible the constant echo of people telling me this situation was not good for my health may have led me to believe that. It’s possible it was the stroke that was the wake up call.

I started searching for an alternative living arrangement for Robert. I checked with his service coordinator. I asked a case worker through his doctor’s office. We visited more than a dozen care homes and were rejected by each one.

Why?? Robert was a very sweet man but he required a lot of care and his seizures were not controlled. He was prone to aspiration pneumonia.

He was too much work for the care homes.

When I did occasionally find respite care it was always at a Skilled Nursing Facility. The SNF was the only facility who could provide the amount of care he needed.

Oh, and me. At my house. My husband and I provided the skilled nursing care only found at a SNF.

We tried to find a caregiver but Robert needed 24/7 care and during the Covid-era it was difficult to find any help at all. Even the day program Robert went to closed and went to remote programs.

Finally, after searching for years and getting rejected over and over again, I found a wonderful Skilled Nursing Facility to take Robert while I had two cataract surgeries. They provided terrific care, I continued advocating for him even though I couldn’t physically care for him and Robert was happy.

When the time came to bring him home I told the facility that I couldn’t do it.

Robert continued to live there and one word reverberated in my head: dumping.

Is that what I’ve done?

Is this how the system should work?

Caregivers get so burnt out their own health suffers and they have to turn to extreme measures?

We had resources: a day program, a Regional Center, were financially comfortable but the physical labor of caring for a 220 lb disabled man with mobility issues, incontinence and seizures and needing full-time assistance with showering, dressing was too much.

The resources were not enough.

The system is designed to “dump” on the family caregiver. And families are designed to “dump” on the eldest sister.

The sister is notoriously programmed to take it all on and then feel guilty when they cannot do it any longer.

I do not regret taking on caregiving for my brother (or for my mom and dad before him) and I certainly don’t begrudge my other brother for not being able to physically care for Robert. This is how we worked it out in our family and he and I are the only ones left.

Mom is gone. Dad is gone and we lost Robert last year.

I love my other brother dearly. My frustration is directed at the healthcare system which demands family caregivers do unpaid work. My frustration is at the healthcare system that prioritizes those who speak the loudest and allows those without an advocate or who cannot advocate for themselves to fall by the wayside.

That’s my frustration. Not at the brothers as depicted in the SNL skit (although I am sure there are many that deserve some ire) and not at the person being cared for who declares the non-caregiver the “golden child.”

It’s the healthcare system. That’s who gets my frustration.

Let’s not let this skit detract us from the real problem of the family caregiver needing more help.

 

No comments: